Skinny all the way

It's just so much... Nicer

I don't mind a little pudge, personally. I don't find emaciated sacks of skin and bones to be all that attractive-nor do I find musle men with 20" biceps to be particularly tempting. Eating disorders (even moderate anorexia) for reasons other than good health is a sign of mental health problems, and a real indicator of an insecure and/or superficial mentality... I find healthy medium-build to (naturally) slim guys to be the better deal-both inside and out.

Short, skinny and defined is awesome. I can't stand the huge, bodybuilder frames with pecs that stick out like a ruler's length.

For me there are just so many variables when considering which be the better! Effectively I'd go for muscles over skin'n'bone - ribs are unattractive.
Yet bizarrely this only extends to guys with a pale complexion. By that I mean tanned skinny guys are far hotter than pale skinny guys, and in the majority of cases I'd go for a tanned skinny over a tanned muscle man.
HOWEVER, put a Mediterranean boney boy up against an well toned and hunky untanned dude, I guess I'd have to go for the latter.
BUT, big muscles (as in so big veins popping out in unexpected places) are a HUUUUGE turn off, and thus inspite of skin complexion I'd prefer a skinny guy.

ANYWAY, I'll stop being greedy taking up so much forum space now!

Big guys are the hottest. (that was PERIOD btw)

It all depends. I'm skinny (not bones... but skinny) and i like a guy who's a tad muscly... not HUGE football player or bodybuilder etc... ill go with everone else. I like swimmers. Hehe

Somewhere in between but defo not too skinny!

Skinny with muscles looks great esp when he's strong and lean. Yum

But muscled guys have worked hard for their body and that's attractive...downside they're sometimes conceited.