 The criteria below must be met in order for an award to be won. The table below is the score sheet used when judging each website. Judges also use a comments and criticisms sheet to assess each site alongside the criteria.
Explanation of the score sheet
A website gaining disqualification points will not be awarded. Websites fulfilling the general criteria as well as collecting at least 6 marks from the other sections will be given a ‘recognition of potential’. Where full marks are gained in each category an award will be given. If full marks are gained in two categories but not all three, a website will be awarded in their strongest category only.
IF AFTER JUDGING YOU WISH TO HAVE A COPY OF YOUR SCORE SHEET, PLEASE SEND YOUR POSTAL ADDRESS TO US FROM THE EMAIL ADDRESS THAT YOU NOMINATED YOURSELF WITH.
DISQUALIFICATION POINTS – NO RECOGNITION IF 1+
Adult Website/Illegal/Corrupt
|
| Under Construction/In Part
|
| No Clear Navigation Style
|
| No Purpose for presence
|
| TOTAL
|
| DISQUALIFIED?
|
|
GENERAL CRITERIA (MUST ACHIEVE 10/10)
Good Navigation
|
| Consistent Brand Image
|
| Good Content flow/Readability
|
| Good Accessibility/Search Engine
|
| Download Time
|
| ICRA if necessary
|
| No broken links (margin of err: 5)
|
| Contact Information Available
|
| Evidence of Panning AND Consistency
|
| Good Uptime (98.9%)
|
| TOTAL
|
| QUALIFY?
|
|
CONTENT AWARD (MUST ACHIEVE 10/10 FOR C/AWARD)
Clear purpose with set goals
|
| Links Available
|
| Well categorized content
|
| Well argued points/Clear structure
|
| Good English (ESU Standard)
|
| ICRA if necessary, Appropriate Lang.
|
| Good use of images with content
|
| Updated Content
|
| Value adding?
|
| Top of class – chair please advice
|
| TOTAL
|
| QUALIFY?
|
|
DESIGN AWARD (MUST ACHIEVE 10/10 FOR C/AWARD)
Effective colour scheme
|
| Excellent use of typography
|
| Very effective navigation
|
| Nav’ reduces content redundancy
|
| New media elements where possible
|
| Excellent use of javascript/css
|
| Design suites purpose well
|
| Good use of white space
|
| Virtually faultless image quality
|
| Mature design & Brand Image
|
| TOTAL
|
| QUALIFY?
|
|
COMMUNITY AWARD (MUST ACHIEVE 10/10 FOR C/AWARD)
Online community presence
|
| Security in place
|
| Management active in community
|
| Fast Registration with Terms & Privacy
|
| Updated and interesting stimulus
|
| Links & Evidence of Networking
|
| Functional technology for interaction
|
| Value Added Experience
|
| Fast interaction
|
| Evidence of planning community
|
| TOTAL
|
| QUALIFY?
|
|
TOP AWARD (MUST ACHIEVE 2/2 FOR C/AWARD)
Unanimous Judge Approval
|
| Meets all criteria
|
| TOTAL
|
| QUALIFY?
|
|
If you have any questions about these critera please contact us.
|
|
Last Updated ( Monday, 16 May 2005 )
|
